Breaking the Bottleneck: Empower Your Team to Make Confident Decisions
Is your team holding decisions for you every time you step away? You come back from a day off and find a pile of 97%-done work just waiting on your sign-off. The frustration is real. And it is not a team failure. It is a development moment.
In this episode of Leadership With a Twist, Heather McGonigal and Barbara Schindler break down exactly what is happening when a capable, well-developed team still defers to their leader for decisions they already know how to make. This is one of the most common bottlenecks in growing organizations, and there is a clear path through it.
Heather and Barbara cover the psychological safety piece that leaders often miss, the unconscious standard-setting that makes teams feel like nothing short of perfect is acceptable, and the decision-making meter that gives team members a concrete tool to move forward with confidence. They also talk about why what used to be a win (checking in before deciding) can quietly become the thing holding everyone back, and how to redefine what winning looks like at this next stage of development.
If you are a leader who wants to stop being the bottleneck, or a team member who is ready to step into greater ownership, this episode is for you
Key Takeaways
- A decision-making bottleneck is not a team failure. It is a signal that the team has grown and the definition of winning needs to be updated.
- Psychological safety is non-negotiable. If your team sees you react to mistakes, they will keep checking in no matter what you say out loud.
- High-achieving team members do not hold back because they are lazy. They hold back because they care about getting it right.
- The decision meter: if you have tapped every resource, checked past decisions, and land at 75% or higher confidence, move forward.
- Redefine winning together. What was the right behavior at one stage of development can become the block at the next.
- Delegation is a two-way street. Both the leader and the team member have a role in moving through this transition.
Action Steps
- Audit your environment for psychological safety. Not what you say about mistakes, but what your team has seen happen after mistakes occur.
- Introduce the decision meter to your team. Define your organization's go threshold (75% is a strong starting point).
- Have the redefine-winning conversation. Explicitly name what great performance looks like at this stage, not the last one.
- Build this into onboarding from day one. Map the phases of development so no one is surprised when the handoff comes.
- If you are a team member, name it. Tell your leader you think you are ready to take ownership on a specific type of decision and ask for the green light.
Questions to Reflect On
- When your team comes to you with a completed decision to approve, do you respond in a way that makes it safe to have gotten it wrong?
- Have you explicitly told your team what kinds of decisions they are now authorized to make without you, or are you expecting them to figure that out on their own?
- As a team member, do you know where your confidence threshold sits, and are you using the resources around you before checking in?
Ready to apply this to your team? Book a complimentary coffee chat with Heather or Barbara and let's talk about breaking your team's decision-making bottleneck in your specific situation: https://www.empoweringleadershipteams.com/coffeechat
About the Hosts: Coach Heather and Coach Barbara are the lead Executive Coaches of Empowering Leadership Teams. They specialize in helping entrepreneurial businesses and their teams meet the moment and become the most empowered they can be to work together and achieve optimal results. With deep expertise in leadership development, team dynamics, and navigating organizational transition, they bring practical, actionable wisdom to leaders facing the challenges of today's rapidly changing business environment.
Weekly Leadership With a Twist Newsletter: https://www.empoweringleadershipteams.com/huddle-subscribe
Subscribe & Review: If you found value in this episode, please subscribe to our podcast and leave us a review. Your feedback helps us create content that serves entrepreneurial leaders like you, and it helps other leaders discover these conversations.
Questions or topics you'd like us to address in future episodes? Send us a message at or leave a comment on our latest post.
Cheering You On!
